But, now, I see that oils, face cream, soap, ect are leaving a shadow! I have had my Quartz for 2 years with no issues. Christina email me as I am also buying new counters (future story here, updating a 17 year old home) and I have found the best stuff! As a general contractor, I suppose I had an advantage, as my old Italian fabricators told me to keep looking every time I came with something they knew I wouldnt be happy with. It does not mark, stain or scratch. I guess Im blessed and wouldnt complain. All this I learned AFTER Id installed quartzite (Actually Calcite) in my kitchen, started cooking and began to notice the un-cleanable etching. According to the fabricator, sea pearl is a hard quartzite.. fresno: Only sealers listed as oil repellant (oleophobic) will repel oil-based substances. The dealer suggested it is part of the natural stone, I should wipe it down with acetone and then seal it. Im interested in quartzite counters for my new kitchen remodel, but I am trying to figure out what the right pricing should be so I dont get taken advantage of. My granite, which is called mont blanc, looks remarkably like quartzite gets heartattack appearing stains from oils and wine. The middle man will tell us what we want to hear, to make the sale. It is extremely important to educate yourself before buying ANY solid surface to make sure that what you want is practical for your household. Resins are natural or synthetic compounds generally originating from tree or plant sap. 2. Will get an earful from me! Will extra sealer help? Its just over 1 year old. Just bought 3 slabs of Quartzite for our new home. Etching can also occur when cleaners that contain hydrofluoric acid are used. I was told that for about $185, they can seal it before install and it will last 15 years. Very bad white etched areas. I have sea pearl quartzite only 6 months old. Luckily the builder is helping out with some of it. I think we all know that marble, especially the lighter colored varieties, can be fussy and prone to staining. Do not use Monte Blanc quartzite. Any advice? I was never careful with red wine, lemon juice in fact I'm sure I cut some directly on the counter top. Actually, the ONLY thing that doesnt etch is Quartz, but be sure you understand the difference between quartzite and quartz. Eighteen months ago, I spent BIG to get the cool quartzite (mislabeled Calcite) that gets new etches with every party and made-from-scratch pot of spaghetti sauce. Thank you for your comments. Those are "stun" marks. Of course this is the first we are hearing of a soft quartzite. I suspect it is actually a calcite being marketed as a quartzite, but I am not a geologist. However, this article states that if quartzite gets damaged, that likely, its not pure quartzite, because pure quartzite isnt really prone to etching, unlike marble, travertine, limestone, and onyx (https://countertopspecialty.freshdesk.com/support/solutions/articles/5000733749-quartzite-etching). Total waste of money. Most marbles are calcites, which will etch when it comes in contact with household acids. Quartzites appearance varies greatly but has distinct veining and can have a look anywhere from crisp solid coloring to very crystalline in appearance (like crushed ice). Portico tile http://www.porticofinetile.com/ Walker Zanger tile http://walkerzanger.com/inspiration/index.php Another favorite kitchen with marble counters and pretty backsplash. Quartzite is a metamorphic rock thats formed when sandstone-based rock is morphed from sand to glassy crystalline with heat and pressure. Here is a reference that can help you http://usenaturalstone.com/definitive-guide-quartzite/. The Lustro is probably fine for light etching. One time ink/magic marker came off of a wet bag and on to the counter. There are tradeoffs to every surface; you'll need to weigh what's most important to you. I household item that can save your countertops! After showing my color scheme and cabinet doors, one of the options shown me was Sea Pearl Quartzite. I was so happy when I first installed these countertop (received soooo many compliments) it was gorgeous. Our polishing process will ensure your quartzite is glossed, protected, and full of shine! It is naturally much sturdier than its imitations; which means you will have a lot less etching, chips, dents, and cracks. Is there anywhere in the tri-state area where I can find good quartzite countertop prices? Very durable surface no issues in 30 years (1990 install). For this reason, the chunk test may not reflect the whole slab. Things went down hill quickly and after two weeks it is literally turning into one giant etching. My wife is a "messy" cook, but we have not found anything that etches or stains the Taj Mahal. What about the White Macabus? Can we add coats of sealer ourselves? I think they are the same. So disappointed. When seeking an all-natural surface, quartzite is the way to go due to its resiliency and durability. And theyre not going to bother to check out where you mention that the article has been updated three times. Its all over. . Now I know to go back with a piece of glass before I make my final selection to determine where my preferred stones lie on the mohs hardness scale, to look out for mesh-backed slabs, and to be glad Im not attracted to the slabs that look like clusters of crystals. Same experience plus tons of cracking and edge chipping. At dinner parties I hate going behind my guest and making sure their glass is sitting on a coaster. The only fix (temporary) would be to have it repolished, but it will reoccur. The quartzite I got had many different names depending on the yard you went to. Others have had no problems at all. The polish can only be restored to a close finish but not to the degree of the factory finish because the factory process involves over 20,000 lbs/ft pressure in obtaining a high shine. They are listed in the first line of this story. Then, we buffed it with shoe polish. Are consumers having this etching problem with Caesarstone? As an example, after being told a sample of super white (also referred to as Brazilian Calcutta by one dealer) did not scratch as badly as a marble sample, but it scratched. . My very limited and semi-scientific testing showed that the Taj Mahal quartzite was impervious to almost any material as far as etching goes. I am sorry you are having so much trouble with your counters. He said some of the marks are the glue marks. We found some beautiful slabs and had a very good installer (who was familiar with Taj Mahalit is challenging to work with) lay it out and install it. Can I add another coat since they just did this yesterday? See if soapstones assets and imperfections will work for you, Every slab of this natural stone is one of a kind but there are things to watch for while you're admiring its unique beauty, Ever classic and with unrivaled beauty, marble countertops bespeak quiet luxury in the kitchen with a few caveats, Sculpted by heat and nonporous by nature, solid-surface countertops bring imagination and low maintenance to the kitchen, Acidic solutions can damage your marble surfaces. Get a sample and do your own tests. [emailprotected]. Im careful and I hate that it doesnt look like a new shiny stone but I could not find one piece of granite that I loved , most are browns and rust or black or grey so Im dealing with the fact that this is what it is because I just love it and it looks beautiful , the etching only shows at certain angles but I agree , we should have been told about this because I would have had a choice , now I have none . As far as staining, I have had 2 rings by the sink(took of the finish), but honestly you would never notice unless I pointed it out. Do they discolor from sun? Some people have had bad problems with staining along the edges where the stone was cut. Of course, we designed the entire space around the island countertop so finding a suitable non-white/non-marble looking replacement has been difficult at best. I have madre perla about 2 months old, that is honed and sealed with a product they wiped on, let sit for 10 mins., and wiped off. Heres how to keep marble looking clean and amazing, Snowy cabinets and walls speak to a certain elegance, while marble counters whisper of luxury, Do you love perfection or patina? So disappointed and I refuse to pay twice (and i cant afford to) so i live with it for the foreseeable future definitely a detraction from my long-saved for, otherwise lovely, $35K custom kitchen. They were not able to pick it out personally. So far, knock wood I have not had a problem. This is a reputable stone yard that just finished the new Nassau Colosseum. Note the hardware and colors in this photo, is this something you might like? And check the country of orgin. It was probably blocking some high-rise owners view:-). Im considering Granite for the cost but REALLY am NOT crazy about the whole speckled look of granites so Im leaning towards Quartzite. I think I read from bill vincent that the better sealants allow liquids to evaporate out. Resins can turn these previously unsellable stones into marketable slabs. UGH. Im not really surprised that it is,now that you bthinknsbout it, since it is pretty translucent, even without having the large crystals. Resin helps protect the stone to a degree but if the stone is in fact calcitic it will still react with acids and etch. This is what Im finding out too. Update Your Homestead Kitchen Countertops On A Budget With Daich Coatings Countertop Refinishing Kit, quartzite colors look A LOT like white marble. How is yours holding up? I was looking at Nuage / Blue Tahoe / ?? No material natural or man made is impervious or indestructible. FYI nearly 90% of granite and quartzites are resin treated to speed in the polishing process since they fill voids within the stone and densify soft areas of the stone. We went back twice to the largest distributor/yard and I found the owner who told me no dont get that one and then the stone I fell in love with and finally chose he said was a very strong one and I would not have problems. Its likely unavoidable and not reversible. No surprise, but he said it is coming out beautifully. Haha. If the whole slab already looks etched and imperfect, post-installation etching wont show as badly. Cost is due to where the stone was mined, how to transport it from its location to you, difficulty in working the stone and its current popularity among other factors. Dont buy high-gloss quartzite, buy a leather or honed finish instead. Thanks! Quartzite is harder than its synthetic alternative, making it less prone to damages. I bought something like a Super White, I forget the name as of now. Mine is madre perla also. Now I am beyond frustrated and dont know what to do. The installer commented on how challenging this stone is to work with (Taj Mahal quartzite). Marble is notorious for etching and staining and cannnot have hot pots on top. So sorry to hear about your experience. I researched and the color I like Nuage happens to be hard so I got lucky! Had I known, I NEVER would have purchased the stone, let alone pay extra over granite. I had a fairly large sample beforehand to test the propensity for etching and couldnt get anything to phase it. Denatured alcohol or acetone is what we used when installing. Id make friends with a reputable stone dealer and email them a picture to get a second opinion. The quartz grains still have space between them. Eliminating the dullness and wear and tear of your quartzite countertops is made possible via care and polishing. We are finishing out a kitchen remodel and got our countertops installed Wednesday. This one has some green in it similar to the photo you like. The salesperson sold me on Luce di Luna which I think is the one yall have mentioned as not actually being quartzite? Real quartzite is harder than granite. Jon , your article was great , very informative . . Heres some photos. So, I guess my question is, do you think I could use an etch remover on my countertop like this one? Some granites also need to be sealed; some of the more dense ones don't. My samples were fine with acids, heat, and didnt etch, but they were small. The fabricator says it is a soft quartzite and behaves more like marble. Short of that there is little reassurance that you are getting anything close to true quartzite. Question: will quartzite with a honed finish, etch the same as a polished surface? It came right off. What do you think about that? My fabricator confirmed this as well. ~boxer, Eye-catching patterns and a natural pedigree make durable quartzite a popular alternative to granite and marble, An engraved island, art-screened cabinets and a smart layout are just the right mix for a professional chef and his wife, Love means accepting maybe even celebrating imperfections. I have been selling solid surface countertops for 15 years. Today I see one of the rings is back and a tiny sticky clearish spot of something left on the countertop left an etch mark after I cleaned it up. Red wine, cola, oil, citrus for over an hour (unsealed) and not a mark no etching at all. Granite will etch as well though.lemon juice can eat through the paint on a car if given enough time. Most people have experience only with one stone, but even they can be helpful by posting the name of their own and how it has performed. Some products that are even specifically made for a surface leave a film. The slab is beautiful, but soon after installation we noticed that everything (even if wiped up immediately) causes it to etch. I recently replaced my windowsills with black granite because nearly every other stone and color would be discolored by the sun. Worth every penny! Here's how to see if marble's right for you, Get details and costs on top counter materials to help you narrow down the choices for your kitchen, Loudoun County's Professional Painting Services & Top-Quality Products, Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers, Outdoor Lighting & Audio/Visual Specialists, http://usenaturalstone.com/definitive-guide-quartzite/, http://usenaturalstone.org/properties-of-quartzite/, Kitchen Counters: Quartzite Offers Strength and Beauty, Kitchen of the Week: Artfully Etched in Denver, Kitchen Counters: Granite, Still a Go-to Surface Choice, Kitchen Counters: Elegant, Timeless Marble, Kitchen Counters: High-Tech Solid Surfaces Make Maintenance Easy, Dream Spaces: 12 Beautiful White Kitchens, Using White Marble: Hot Debate Over a Classic Beauty, Your Guide to 15 Popular Kitchen Countertop Materials, Polished Hammered Stainless Steel Kitchen Sink, Kitchen backsplash tile above 4 inch granitr, Ideas for finishing top of cabinets after soffit removal. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. What would your advice be? A stones shine should be honed into it, not topically applied. We wanted something white, but it had to be stain and etch proof so we kept looking for this quartzite and finally found some gorgeous slabs that were close enough. Perhaps, but at what cost? I swear, even waterdrops will etch this stone. Please check your entries and try again. True quartzite as the term is properly used is close to 99% pure quartz. I have the exact same problem. They are also repairable, but scratch more easily than most stones. My quartz countertop was installed 10 days ago. I knew it had to happen sooner or later, but the kitchen isn't even done and there it was this morningplain as day, one big old circle etch on the counter. Real quartzite is already etch-proof. In Toronto 2 book-matched slabs cost me $8k wholesale and cutting and installations, another $8knot a straight forward layout. How can I find a glossary of hard and soft quartzites? LOL. At the very least, if (fake) quartzite continues to be sold, it should include the cost of a sealer like Clearstone as part of the deal. No. Jon Anderson is CandysDirt.com's condo/HOA and developer columnist, but also covers second home trends on SecondShelters.com. Javiwa, are you saying with that sealer that oil etc won't be absorbed into quartzite? NEVER use a topical/high-gloss sealer on natural stone. https://candysdirt.com/2015/09/18/uchi-uchi-coo-showroom-event-aria-stone-gallery/. Hey, I was on here looking for other names for Nuage for you when I saw this. Were going through something very similar with a stone that was sold to us as Polar Vortex Granite which actually turns out to be a Brazilian dolomitic marble. My countertops were back to normal!!!! We originally wanted something a bit more white, but practicality won out and we are very happy with our choice. I just dont want to blatantly turn away from using it right off because of a few bad stories. I called and was told to go ahead and reseal now and all will be fixed. Linda. There suggestions ranging from re-polishing to clear-coating it. It isnt the immediate spill, its the acid being left active post cleanup without a neutralizing cleaner. Read my follow up here. I've only dealt with quartzite once and it's a bitch. Any oil smudges and splatters left overnight wipe up fine with soap and water. Not to beat a dead horse but if someone could help, wed be so appreciative! But now I just opened my summer house after shutting electricity for the winter and I see reddish marks on quartzite!! There's a list of different quartzites in this article http://usenaturalstone.org/properties-of-quartzite/ - hopefully that gives you a few to start with. This is not your fault, but was the fault of the people who sold you that stone under the wrong name and with an incorrect description of its properties. The salesperson at KLZ even told us that some of the super white quartzite is not actually quartzite and is really marble, but assured us that the platinum pearl we were buying is quartzite. Don't buy quartzite. I would never have purchased it, had I known, as I did not purchase Marble because of the etching . Imperfections in your quartziteincluding dullnesscan be frustrating! The fact that your supplier tried to pass off the problem as an unknowable, uncontrollable manufacturing problem makes me suspicious on many levels. I read this just in time it seems! An award-winning columnist, Jon has earned silver and bronze awards for his columns from the National Association of Real Estate Editors in both 2016, 2017 and 2018. My fabricator came and literally sanded it down and it looked beautiful again. All natural stones are different compositions. I can think of many adjectives Id like to use to describe you, but I will refrain. Stone sourcing regions make a huge difference in the features of the stone. Quartzite is naturally occurring and Quartz is man made? We are having it replaced and despite admitting it was their issue mislabeling the stone they arent giving us one red cent of help. Learn to love them until you replace the top; more are on the way. Im not a lawyer nor do I play one on TV. I Purchased my honed quartzite counter from a stone dealer through whom I had done business for 10 years with highly satisfied results of three different kitchen and bath granite installations. OK, so almost three months later and I have to say I am very pleased with our choice for countertops (Taj Mahal Quartzite). JB, NOVA Stone Care is a natural stone restoration and maintenance company. Once shimmed there should not be ongoing stresses that are being applied to your countertop. The white marble that my neighbour bought from Brazil was ruined the first weekend after installation from beer bottle stains, where as the almost identical marble from Italy would not have been. I want something with green or blue in it that isnt too dark and doesnt etch! Similar to the original poster, we had a spill of something very acidic on our Caesarstone countertop and it etched away the top layer in a section of the countertop. But when acidic liquids wine, tomatoes, citrus, etc. I asked ten times as I am aware of all the look alike stones. I have had my countertops a year and I am NOT an avid cooker so my kitchen activity is minimal. Etching: SOME Quartzites (and Onyxs and Marbles) Dirty Secret. Luckily I have not installed it, but the rest of my kitchen is chosen based on that countertop. FYI I believe the quartzite in figure 2 is called Fusion and is from Italy. Very happy with our choice! Thank you for responding. This is a very informative column. Ive also included those links in the beginning of this article. Many would think durability, along with stone rarity, should increase with price. Duh. Polishing your quartzite leaves your counter with a very glossy finish that is vibrant and reflective. A third suggestion Ive read is the most specious. Sorry so many are unhappy with such a product that many cant afford. thanks. It pits the stone and can cause a stone ailment called spalling that you DO NOT want. Thanks for this informative post! As of a month ago, the same place that sold me calcite as quartzite has simply removed labeling and places it alongside granite and quartzite. Is the color you are looking for sort of like the color in the creamy beige in that photo? Man-made quartz products include Ceasarstone, Silestone, Cambria, Samsung, Vitra stone etc. She thought quarts was a more modern product, than granite. Consumer reports and other testing organizations rank Quartz higher than Granite for durability, although both are typically suggested as good choices overall. Let me know if you need help with this. In other words, the same cost to throw these finicky counters off the roof and install carefree un-etchable granite! Natuaral quartzites are actually harder than granite and will not etch. Anyone know about this? Regardless of what you eventually choose for your countertops, you'll need to do more research so you know what you're getting into. Hi! Some will label granites as quartzite. Some will even label marbles which contain calcite and etch as Quartzite. I am having huge issues with the quartzite counters where the cut edges let in moisture, discoloring the edge and increasing areas on the top surface. Theres another wrinkle to this also. Although regular cleaning and maintenance at home on your own will take care of much of the day-to-day spills and messes, your quartzite will require a bit more attention professionally from time-to-time. WHY? Aside from that, it's a great choice. but cant find much information. While well intentioned for the most part, there is a a lot of misinformation and personal opinions that can steer you in the wrong direction. I am sorry that your dealer sold you stuff that etches. Consumer reports and several other testing groups rank Quartz as more durable than granite, although CR suggests that both are good choices. Reasonable care and expectations will go a long ways towards a satisfactory experience too.Thanks to all who contributed to this thread and this forum! ^^^especially the etching test (scroll ~ halfway down the page), as your stone has already, unfortunately, failed the scratch test (i.e., too soft to be quartzite). - A Very Cozy Home, This North Dallas Home Looks So Good Youll Think Its Staged, Frank Talley Designed This Super Cool Modern in Fort Worths Westover Hills. Seems like this thread is relatively active. I was considering quartzite for a kitchen counter. Houzz Pro: One simple solution for contractors and design pros. https://imgur.com/gallery/EBd6M18. The wrapper from the sponges got wet and left an ink stain who knew that was possible. Also, true quartzite does not etch for the simple reason that it effectively contains no calcite. My biggest problem is that I was not told. Someone mentioned sea pearl quartzite. This column still stands as a cautionary tale. Test test test! Shoot Jon an email. Dont even think about putting down a glass without a coaster. So while everything you write about resins is true, granite will not solve anyones problem in fact, its pretty much *guaranteed* to etch in any form, while un-resind quartzite will not. I am obsessed with every etch in the stone and work on trying to fix it every day and every day my efforts fail. I have the same problem. All that should do to real quartzite is clean it. In my experience and, according to my installer, for dark granite sealing is not necessary. Sealer can always be applied as long as its impregnating and the surface is clean. Natural stone MUST be sealed on a regular basis (every 12-18 months), and even then, it can still be stained or etched. Press J to jump to the feed. shear style said they had good results getting etching out of quartzite using Lustro Italiano? I am considering Quartzite Calacutta Leathered. Use a pH neutral cleaner at all times and it will neutralize the acid in the spill. Those beautiful swirls of color you see in some sheets come from other chemical impurities which may be prone to etching, but I have yet to see an actual quartzite slab that ever contained what looked like the large, shattered quartz crystals that you can see in Figure 1, because real quartzite is made when tectonic pressures and temperatures transforms quartz sandstone in to metamorphic rock. Recently I spoke with IMC, my stone supplier, and they were surprised to hear that no one had warned me. Hey Heather thank you so much for your explanation ,right now I am looking for this Stone ,Give me your opinion please ,I am interesting in quartzite name Midnight Crystal.is multi color ,do you think this stone good as your, how can I get more prove is not fake.i live in South Central FL ? Taj Mahal does not need a sealer to prevent etch OR staining because of its very high quartz content. We used a VERY fine sandpaper and lightly smoothed the area. because of course its granite. An average Kitchen for me runs around $1000 on quartzite and cheaper for marble or limestone as theyre softer and much easier to work with. She uses Method spray on it. Its true, its very costly to restore the stone but still much cheaper than an entire overhaul of new stone being installed which can be upwards of $15-25K. Quartz should not etch and is heat resistant. I frequently use lemon and lime for cooking and drinks and its been fine. Great choice. I'm not sure if white countertops that are etched would soak in any of the color of the olive oil. Fully restored leathered quartzite countertops. Nope, not once in the dozen-ish trips I made to IMC nor at any of the other stone yards in Dallas I visited, (including Allied Stone). Doing a Google search is when this article same up, so I started to worry. It etches with even water! On a whim, I figured that etch is very dry and thought maybe putting moisture back into these areas would help, and if not, most likely wouldnt hurt. Quartzite Countertops May be Gorgeous, But Theres Something Your Stone Dealer Isnt Telling You. We have had ours for well over a year now with ZERO etching or staining issues and it is beautiful. Several possibilities (caveat: I'm no expert, but I did do a fair amount of research on this) the most likely is that you were sold something other than true quartzite. But Ive also read that etching can occur at differing rates on the same slab because some areas will have more/deeper resin than others.
Tuff Duck Marble Sealer, Maternity Terry Cloth Robe, Pacsun Light Blue Mom Jeans, Gemstones By Bead Landing, Sunscreen Spray Costco,
0 Comment